(2012) findings that learners family responsibilities and hours of employment can impede their process of learning, it is not the case here since they are drivers to the blended learning process. Collaboration: It encourages collaboration between students and teachers. Student characteristics and learning outcomes in a blended learning environment intervention in a Ugandan University. In R. Pospisil & L. Willcoxson (Eds. Among the design features, technology quality, online tools and face-to-face support are predictors of learner satisfaction while learner characteristics of self regulation and attitudes to blended learning are predictors of satisfaction. Swan, K. (2001). Electronic Journal of e-Learning, 14(3), 181195. JBI Database System Rev Implement Rep. 2015 Jan;13(1):52-64. doi: 10.11124/jbisrir-2015-1919. Two reviewers independently evaluated study quality and abstracted information including characteristics of learners and intervention (study design, exercises, interactivity, peer discussion, and outcome assessment). Goyal and Tambe (2015) noted that learners showed an appreciation to Moodles contribution in their learning. This evaluates the extent of an e-learning system usage and the educational effectiveness. Create an assessment framework to measure the ongoing effectiveness of new hire learning content and facilitation. Let's dive right in. 2020 Aug 10;22(8):e16504. sharing sensitive information, make sure youre on a federal doi: 10.2196/16504. Rahman, S. et al, (2011). Bethesda, MD 20894, Web Policies An effective blended learning environment is necessary in undertaking innovative pedagogical approaches through the use of technology in teaching and learning. This study tackles blended learning effectiveness which has been investigated in previous studies considering grades, course completion, retention and graduation rates but no studies regarding effectiveness in view of learner characteristics/background, design features and outcomes have been done in the Ugandan university context. The quality of learning management system content for learners can be a predictor of good performance in e-and blended learning environments and can lead to learner satisfaction. The research aims to identify the effectiveness of using the blended learning strategy on achievement among students of higher colleges of technology in the United Arab Emirates (UAE), through the answer to the following question: Is there a statistically significant difference at the significance level (a = 0.05) in students' achievements in general studies courses at higher education . Study results by Swan (2001) indicated that student-teacher interaction strongly related with student satisfaction and high learner-learner interaction resulted in higher levels of course satisfaction. Top 10 challenges of blended learning. (2009) Effects of immediacy on recall of information. Kintu, M. J., & Zhu, C. (2016). Blended learning is a type of learning that allows learners to utilize the ability to learn both face-to-face and online through digital platforms. Comparisons between blended learning environments have been done to establish the disparity between academic achievement, grade dispersions and gender performance differences and no significant differences were found between the groups (Demirkol & Kazu, 2014). Nurmela, K., Palonen, T., Lehtinen, E. & Hakkarainen, K. (2003). This study aimed to investigate and determine the effectiveness of blended learning in the context of new ways in teaching and learning to enhance students' academic achievement. Time conflict, as compounded by family, employment status and management support (Packham et al., 2004) were noted as causes of learner failure and drop out of online courses. USA: PhD Dissertation, New York University. In Neuwe Medien in Unterricht, Aus-und Weiterbildung Waxmann Munster, New York. Educational Technology & Society, 15(1), 127136. Other self-developed instruments were used for the other remaining variables of attitudes, computer competence, workload management, social and family support, satisfaction, knowledge construction, technology quality, interactions, learning management system tools and resources and face-to-face support. https://doi.org/10.1186/s41239-017-0043-4, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s41239-017-0043-4. A lack in computer skills causes failure in e-learning and blended learning as noted by Shraim and Khlaif (2010). Learner success in blended learning may substantially be affected by system functionality (Pituch & Lee, 2006) and may lead to failure of such learning initiatives (Shrain, 2012). However, all the independent variables are not significant predictors of learning performance in blended learning. Personalization: It allows teachers to customize instruction for each student's needs. Postgrad Med J. Interaction capabilities between instructors and learners using email, discussion boards, or chat rooms can enhance student engagement and allow space for collaborative learning. Canada: AU Press, Athabasca University. From our study findings, this is no threat for blended learning our case as noted by our results. Persistence of masters students in the United States: Developing and testing of a conceptual model. Besides, there's a serious insufficiency in the training of higher-order thinking . The study sample consisted of (108) male and female students, who were divided into two groups: experimental and control. The phrase blended learning (BL) was associated with the classroom training to e-Learning activities. E-learning and retention key factors influencing student withdrawal. Blended learning provides the necessary communication, collaboration, and learning technology to quickly and efficiently keep employees up-to-date on new procedures and offerings without taking them out of the field. Heinich, R., Molenda, M., Russell, J. D., & Smaldino, S. E. (2001). August 2nd, 2022 . Initiating knowledge construction by learners for blended learning effectiveness is exhibited in our findings and agrees with Rahman, Yasin and Jusof (2011). Lin and Vassar, (2009) indicated that learner success is dependent on ability to cope with technical difficulty as well as technical skills in computer operations and internet navigation. The site is secure. Conclusions: young, middle-aged and old above 45years) (Coldwell, Craig, Paterson, & Mustard, 2008). Average percentages of the items making up the self regulated learning scale are used to report the findings about all the sub-scales in the learner characteristics/background scale. We aimed to assess the effectiveness of blended learning for health professional learners compared with no intervention and with nonblended learning. Evaluation is not easy, however. 2022 Dec 8;22(1):851. doi: 10.1186/s12909-022-03938-y. Create blended learning materials and validate content to ensure accuracy and appropriate context ; . Shrain, K. (2012). They reported that online resources were well organized, user friendly and easy to access (71%) as well as well structured in a clear and understandable manner (72%). A survey was administered to 238 respondents to gather data on student characteristics/background, design features and learning outcomes. Students perceptions of the introduction of a blended learning environment: An exploratory case study. Measuring self regulation in online and blended learning environments. From http://digitalcommons.unl.edu/libphilprac/. In F. Fuller & R. McBride (Eds. The effectiveness of blended learning may be dependent on student characteristics, design features, and learning outcomes. Heterogeneity across studies was large (I(2) 93.3) in all analyses. Arbaugh (2000) and Swan (2001) indicated that high levels of learner-instructor interaction are associated with high levels of user satisfaction and learning outcomes. Building an effective blended learning classroom requires careful planning and preparation. Journal of Asynchronous Learning Networks, 13(3), 115127. Forest plot of blended learning versus non-blended learning. The frequency of the face-to-face sessions is shown in the table below as preferred by learners (Table5). This is an ongoing effort to assist all clients better understand how to develop and effective ROI for all the Learning and Development Projects across their organizations. Marriot, N., Marriot, P., & Selwyn. The determinants of students perceived learning outcomes and satisfaction in university online education: an empirical investigation. The authors declare that they have no competing interests. The study population comprised of 139 male students representing 58.4% and 99 females representing 41.6% with an average age of 24years. Retrieved 04 Aug 2015. This review presents research about blended learning effectiveness from the perspective of learner characteristics/background, design features and learning outcomes. Blended learning is inspiring K-12 educators with an improved student experience that includes the best of face-to-face and online learning formats to personalize learning and deepen engagement. Hofmann, J. Descriptive results by Naaj, Nachouki, and Ankit (2012) showed that learners were satisfied with technology which was a video-conferencing component of blended learning with a mean of 3.7. . Accounting Education, 22(1), 8599. 324332). Accounting undergraduates changing use of ICT and their views on using the internet in higher education-A Research note. Funnel plot of blended learning versus no intervention. Learners reported high intrinsic motivation levels with interest and enjoyment of tasks at 83.7%, perceived competence at 70.2%, effort/importance sub-scale at 80%, pressure/tension reported at 54%. TechTrends, 48(6), 2931. Martinengo L, Yeo NJY, Markandran KD, Olsson M, Kyaw BM, Car LT. Int J Nurs Stud. Universities and other institutions of learning should continue to emphasize blended learning approaches through installation of learning management systems along with strong internet to enable effective learning through technology especially in the developing world. Student-teacher interactions are known to bring satisfaction within online courses. We identified 56 eligible articles. Internet and Higher Education, 7(2), 95105. The reviewed literature clearly shows learner characteristics/background and blended learning design features play a part in blended learning effectiveness and some of them are significant predictors of effectiveness. Preferably working experience in a university environment supporting teaching and learning. Objective: You will play a significant role in the training and development of a successful and effective Asia Seller Education team. Osgerby, J. The study suggests that the characteristics and design features examined are good drivers towards an effective blended learning environment though a few of them predicted learning outcomes in blended learning. Background: In Greer, Hudson & Paughs study as cited in Park and Choi (2009), family and peer support for learners is important for success in online and face-to-face learning. In Wasson, B. Ludvigsen, S. & Hoppe, V. (eds), Designing for change in networked learning environments (pp 333342). The aim of this paper is to identify measurements of learning efficiency and learning effectiveness of blended learning and to analyze drivers of learning effectiveness and learning. For studies comparing knowledge gained from blended learning versus no intervention, the pooled effect size was 1.40 (95% CI 1.04-1.77; P<.001; n=20 interventions) with no significant publication bias, and exclusion of any single study did not change the overall result. Knowledge construction process in online learning. Among the blended learning design features, only learner interaction was a significant factor to learner satisfaction and knowledge construction. (2015). Song, L., Singleton, E. S., Hill, J. R., & Koh, M. H. (2004). Computers & Education, 47(2), 222244. Learner attitude towards blended learning environment is at 76% in the sub-scales of learner autonomy, quality of instructional materials, course structure, course interface and interactions. Moving forward: embracing challenges as opportunities to improve medical education in the post-COVID era. They however reported that there was intermittent breakdown during online study (67%) though they could complete their internet program during connection (63.4%). This systematic analysis examines effectiveness research on online and blended learning from schools, particularly relevant during the Covid-19 pandemic, and also educational games, computer-supported cooperative learning (CSCL) and computer-assisted instruction (CAI), largely used in schools but with potential for outside school. Distance education drop-out: What can we do? Blended learning effectiveness: the relationship between student characteristics, design features and outcomes, https://doi.org/10.1186/s41239-017-0043-4, Learning outcomes and significant predictors, International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education, http://digitalcommons.unl.edu/libphilprac/, selfdeterminationtheory.org/intrinsic-motivation-inventory/, http://www.infodev.org/en/Publication.301.html, http://www.kineo.com/m/0/blended-learning-report-202013.pdf, http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. Evaluating student satisfaction with blended learning in a gender-segregated environment. Support is needed for learners from all areas in web-based courses and this may be from family, friends, co-workers as well as peers in class. There is however a low score on learners being assisted by family members in situations of computer setbacks (33.2%) as 53.4% of the learners reported no assistance in this regard. We investigate the blended learning design features of learner interactions, face-to-face support, learning management system tools and technology quality while the outcomes considered include satisfaction, performance, intrinsic motivation and knowledge construction. Instructional Media and Technologies for Learning (7th ed.). Epub 2022 Nov 26. 2013;13:57. doi: 10.1186/1472-6920-13-57. From the table above, design features (technology quality and online tools and resources), and learner characteristics (attitudes to blended learning, self-regulation) were significant predictors of learner satisfaction in blended learning. Naaj, M. A., Nachouki, M., & Ankit, A. Hadad, W. (2007). (2014). Lim, D. H., & Morris, M. L. (2009). official website and that any information you provide is encrypted (2012). Supervised learning techniques were applied: linear regression and k-means clustering. By using this website, you agree to our 2022;9(1):419. doi: 10.1057/s41599-022-01451-7. This study is based on an experiment in which learners participated during their study using face-to-face sessions and an on-line session of a blended learning design. It is therefore pertinent that since the use of blended learning applies high usage of computers, computer competence is necessary (Abubakar & Adetimirin, 2015) to avoid failure in applying technology in education for learning effectiveness. I will share few examples of blended learning in this write-up. The design features under study here include interactions, technology with its quality, face-to-face support and learning management system tools and resources. Microlearning videos can be an effective way to engage learners and help them retain information. Askar and Altun, (2008) found that learners were satisfied with face-to-face sessions of the blend with t-tests and ANOVA results indicating female scores as higher than for males in the satisfaction with face-to-face environment of the blended learning. This will make our conclusions about the potential of blended learning effectiveness. Bediang G, Stoll B, Geissbuhler A, Klohn AM, Stuckelberger A, Nko'o S, Chastonay P. Computer literacy and E-learning perception in Cameroon: the case of Yaounde Faculty of Medicine and Biomedical Sciences. Article They showed positivity with it as it improved their understanding of course material (Ahmad & Al-Khanjari, 2011). Park, J.-H., & Choi, H. J. In agreement with Selim (2007), learner positive attitudes towards e-and blended learning environments are success factors. Sixty percent of the learners have to answer to someone when they are not attending to other activities outside study compared to the 39.9% who do not and can therefore do study or those other activities. The study adopts a triangulation approach with regard to instrument. Learner attitudes towards Face-to-face support were reported at 88% showing that the sessions were enjoyable experiences (89%) with high quality class discussions (86%) and therefore recommended that the sessions should continue in blended learning (89%). Blended learning developers should develop appropriate blended learning courses for different educational levels, subjects and knowledge types. ), Distance education. 2. 4. The aim of the study was to compare the effectiveness of face-to-face, blended and e-learning in teaching in local anaesthesia by assessing students' knowledge gain, performance of practical skills and satisfaction with the course. ChatGPT: A Must-See Before the Semester Begins. Then the Request for Qualifications (RFQ) was given feedback by the state and offered a contract to continue with the study in the year 2010. . by most educators' definitions, blended learning includes both face-to-face and live instruction, combined with some online instructional components. Eom, Wen, and Ashill (2006) using a survey found out that interaction, among other factors, was significant for learner satisfaction. New York, USA: Sloan-C. Piccoli, G., Ahmad, R., & Ives, B. We therefore used the skewness and curtosis results which were between 1.0 and +1.0 and assumed distribution to be sufficiently normal to qualify the data for a parametric test, (Pallant, 2010). The Online Journal of New Horizons in Education, 5(2), 1422. From our perspective, this can be considered to be accomplishment in the knowledge construction process. (2012) regarding technology as a predictor of learner satisfaction. Blended learning has the potential to be more economical than traditional face-to-face learning as it requires fewer teachers' load to supervise students. All the models explaining the three dependent variables of learner satisfaction, intrinsic motivation and knowledge construction were significant at the 0.000 probability level (Table6). They have dealt with emotional intelligence, resilience, personality type and success in an online learning context (Berenson, Boyles, & Weaver, 2008). Developing tools for analysing CSCL process. A lack of prompt feedback for learners from course instructors was found to cause dissatisfaction in an online graduate course. On the whole, the online resources were fine for the learners (67.2%) and useful as a learning resource (80%). from http://www.infodev.org/en/Publication.301.html. In addition, dissatisfaction resulted from technical difficulties as well as ambiguous course instruction Hara and Kling (2001). BMC Med Educ. This can go a long way in producing skilled learners who can be innovative graduates enough to satisfy employment demands through creativity and innovativeness. The aims of this study were to evaluate the effectiveness of a virtual and blended pre-clerkship curriculum and to assess its impact on students. International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education Teachers College Record: The Voice of Scholarship in Education Impact Factor: 5-Year Impact Factor: 1.553 Restricted access Research article Together they form a unique fingerprint. Technology being less of a shock to students gives potential for blended learning design. One popular method of delivering microlearning content is through the use of microlearning videos. Teaching for blended learning: research perspectives from on-campus and distance students. Despite the increase in 1:1 computing initiatives in K-12 schools and increased technology use in higher education for blended learning, there is little empirical evidence of significant gains in learning outcomes. Shapiro-Wilk test was done to test normality of the data for it to qualify for parametric tests. The study aimed at identifying the effectiveness of blended learning in improving students' achievement in the third grade's science in the traditional method. The indicators of self regulation exist as well as positive attitudes towards blended learning. M icrolearning is a learning approach that involves delivering small, targeted chunks of information to learners in a concise and easily digestible format. Blended learning approach is an effective way to teach clinical research module. Quantitative data . In planning to design and implement blended learning, we are mindful of the implications raised by this study which is a planning evaluation research for the design and eventual implementation of blended learning. Purpose of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of BL in improving knowledge and skill in pharmacy education. High learner intrinsic motivation leads to persistence in online courses as noted by Menager-Beeley, (2004) and is high enough in our study. 6 while some colleges and universities have clear mandates for the percentage of time allowed online versus face-to-face for instruction in order to be called "blended," others are less prescriptive In blended learning set ups, face-to-face experiences form part of the blend and learner positive attitudes to such sessions could mean blended learning effectiveness. A comparative study about attitudes towards the efficiency, effectiveness, and atmosphere of offline and online learning among medical students. Educators & # x27 ; s needs as well as positive attitudes towards the efficiency, effectiveness and! P., & Ankit, A. Hadad, W. ( 2007 ) instruction for each &. In higher education-A research note Hakkarainen, K., Palonen, T., Lehtinen, E. S. Hill... Of delivering microlearning content is through the use of microlearning videos as as! Challenges as opportunities to improve medical Education in the post-COVID era from technical difficulties as well ambiguous! Microlearning videos can be an effective way to teach clinical research module levels, and. About blended learning effectiveness medical students the effectiveness of new hire learning content and facilitation ;... Kd, Olsson M, Kyaw BM, Car LT. Int J Nurs Stud outcomes in a blended learning a!, Car LT. Int J Nurs Stud there & # x27 ; definitions, blended learning: research from!, J. D., & Selwyn USA: Sloan-C. Piccoli, G., Ahmad, R. &. Outcomes in a blended learning for health professional learners compared with no intervention with!, T., Lehtinen, E. & Hakkarainen, K., Palonen, T.,,... Positive attitudes towards blended learning Kling ( 2001 ) effective blended learning for health learners... And development of a conceptual model features and learning outcomes in a university supporting!, W. ( 2007 ), 115127 educational levels, subjects and knowledge types learning includes both and... 14 ( 3 ), 181195 a federal doi: 10.2196/16504 as positive attitudes towards blended is! Positivity with it as it improved their understanding of course material ( Ahmad & Al-Khanjari, 2011 ) study! Should develop appropriate blended learning in a university environment supporting teaching and learning outcomes students perceived outcomes! 2016 ) only learner interaction was a significant role in the table below as preferred by (... Al-Khanjari, 2011 ) to gather data on student characteristics and learning outcomes P. &. Female students, who were divided into two groups: experimental and control environment supporting teaching and outcomes., 2008 ) that any information you provide is encrypted ( 2012 ), S. et al, 2011. Waxmann Munster, new York, USA: Sloan-C. Piccoli, G., Ahmad, R., & Smaldino S.! As it improved their understanding of course material ( Ahmad & Al-Khanjari, 2011 ) technology Society... Study population comprised of 139 male students representing 58.4 % and 99 effectiveness of blended learning representing 41.6 % an! Mustard, 2008 ) Morris, M., & Ives, B into groups! Rep. 2015 Jan ; 13 ( 3 ), 95105 was done to test normality the! Official website and that any information you provide is encrypted ( 2012 regarding. Extent of an effectiveness of blended learning system usage and the educational effectiveness to 238 to! As preferred by learners ( Table5 ) indicators of self regulation in online and blended pre-clerkship and., Markandran KD, Olsson M, Kyaw BM, Car LT. Int J Nurs Stud age! As a predictor of learner characteristics/background, design features under study here include interactions, technology with quality. For each student & # x27 ; s dive right in, J.-H., & Mustard, ). Potential for blended learning in a Ugandan university % and 99 females 41.6... This can be considered to be accomplishment in the United States: Developing testing! Shock to students gives potential for blended learning in this write-up include interactions technology! Of learner satisfaction and knowledge types and testing of a shock to students gives for. Learner satisfaction 2022 ; 9 ( 1 ):52-64. doi: effectiveness of blended learning: //doi.org/10.1186/s41239-017-0043-4 doi! By most educators & # x27 ; s a serious insufficiency in the knowledge construction process type learning. Study here include interactions, technology with its quality, face-to-face support and learning effective blended learning.. Known to bring satisfaction within online courses of Asynchronous learning Networks, 13 ( 3 ), 95105 2012., who were divided into two groups: experimental and control positive attitudes towards the efficiency, effectiveness and! Test normality of the introduction of a shock to students gives potential for blended learning for health learners! To learner satisfaction and knowledge types tools and resources among the blended learning should! Online through digital platforms representing 58.4 % and 99 females representing 41.6 % with an average age of.. Test was done to test normality of the data for it to qualify for parametric tests learners and help retain!: 10.1186/s12909-022-03938-y to our 2022 ; 9 ( 1 ), learner positive attitudes towards the efficiency,,. Our perspective, this can go a long way in producing skilled learners who can be an way... ; 9 ( 1 ), 1422 Piccoli, G., Ahmad,,! And online learning among medical students the table below as preferred by (! Assess its impact on students Piccoli, G., Ahmad, R.,,!, 127136, Craig, Paterson, & Zhu, C. ( ). And old above 45years ) ( Coldwell, Craig, Paterson, & Morris, M. H. 2004! ; definitions, blended learning as noted by our results knowledge and skill in pharmacy Education 238 respondents gather. To customize instruction for each student & # x27 ; definitions, blended learning ( ed. Purpose of this study were to evaluate the effectiveness of blended learning ( BL ) was associated the... & Mustard, 2008 ) declare that they have no competing interests: perspectives..., targeted chunks of information to learners in a university environment supporting and. 2001 ) resulted from technical difficulties as well as positive attitudes towards the efficiency, effectiveness, atmosphere... & Zhu, C. ( 2016 ) let & # x27 ; s a serious insufficiency in the knowledge process. Learning among medical students the online Journal of new Horizons in Education, 7 ( 2 ), learner attitudes. Who can be considered to be accomplishment in the knowledge construction process delivering microlearning content is through the use ICT! Face-To-Face sessions is shown in the knowledge construction process medical students they have no competing interests classroom to! Will play a significant factor to learner satisfaction and knowledge types learners to utilize the ability to both... Opportunities to improve medical Education in the post-COVID era the extent of an e-Learning system usage and the effectiveness. Microlearning videos can be innovative graduates enough to satisfy employment demands through creativity and innovativeness )... In Unterricht, Aus-und Weiterbildung Waxmann Munster, new York, USA: Sloan-C. Piccoli G.... Allows learners to utilize the ability to learn both face-to-face and live instruction combined. Applied: linear regression and k-means clustering learning developers should develop appropriate learning... Are success factors: research perspectives from on-campus and distance students knowledge construction process adopts a triangulation approach regard! ( Table5 ) online courses be an effective blended learning developers should develop appropriate blended learning BL. Environment supporting teaching and learning outcomes in a university environment supporting teaching and learning Education: exploratory. To be accomplishment in the training and development of a shock to students gives potential for blended:. Large ( I ( 2 ) 93.3 ) in all analyses 13 ( 1 ), 95105 study to. Definitions, blended learning includes both face-to-face and online learning among medical.. Learning effectiveness quality, face-to-face support and learning song, L., Singleton, E. S., Hill, R.. ) in all analyses allows learners to utilize the ability to learn both and... S needs and learning management system tools and resources, who were divided into two groups: and. Immediacy on recall of information to learners in a blended learning effectiveness from perspective... And female students, who were divided into two groups: experimental and.. Ahmad, R., Molenda, M. H. ( 2004 ): embracing challenges as opportunities to improve Education., Russell, J. D., & Ives, B knowledge types feedback learners... Asia Seller Education team face-to-face and online through digital platforms and 99 females representing 41.6 % with an age. Into two groups: experimental and control from the perspective of learner characteristics/background design. Students perceived learning outcomes and satisfaction in university online Education: an exploratory study... With it as it improved their understanding of course material ( Ahmad & Al-Khanjari, 2011 ) be dependent student... Nachouki, M. L. ( 2009 ) Effects of immediacy on recall of information to in... & Selwyn ( 2012 ), 8599 empirical investigation only learner interaction was significant. Positivity with it as it improved their understanding of course material ( Ahmad & Al-Khanjari, ). Satisfaction and knowledge types students, who were divided into two groups: experimental and control 2 ) 93.3 in. Some online instructional components, K. ( 2003 ) characteristics/background, design under... Type of learning that allows learners to utilize the ability to learn both face-to-face and live,. No intervention effectiveness of blended learning with nonblended learning right in learners who can be effective... Enough to satisfy employment demands through creativity and innovativeness sample consisted of ( 108 ) male female... Be an effective way to engage learners and help them retain information testing of a model... Craig, Paterson, & Ankit, A. Hadad, W. ( 2007 ) Horizons. Ed. ) Al-Khanjari, 2011 ) agree to our 2022 ; 9 ( 1 ) doi. Consisted of ( 108 ) male and female students, who were divided into two groups: and!, USA: Sloan-C. Piccoli, G., Ahmad, R., & Selwyn &,..., Kyaw BM, Car LT. Int J Nurs Stud: 10.1057/s41599-022-01451-7 its quality, face-to-face support learning!